
Ranching
has never been an easy life or an easy living. In the mid 1980's it
got tougher. High interest rates,

an excess of expensive, financed farm equipment, overpriced agricultural
land, and flat or declining agricultural commodity and beef prices changed
the ranching equation forever. These factors coupled with the exceptional
growth in fly fishing/outdoor recreation baby boomer leisure time and
wealth resulted in the greatest sell off of ranch land in the history
of the United States. It is these events which became the foundation
for the growth in Conservation Easement grants.
What
is a Conservation Easement? In its simplest form a Conservation
Easement is best described as the grant by deed by an owner (Grantor)
to a charitable organization (Grantee) of all or a portion of certain
of the bundle of rights that are a part of private property ownership,
including very specifically future development and construction rights.
The formula for computing the value of this donation is complicated.
Simply, after including a host of factors such as enhancement, (ie
the increase in value of rights reserved on the p
roperty,
after the grant of the easement), there is a value attached to the
rights that are being given away. This value, (once all the i’s are
dotted, t’s are crossed, proper documentation drawn, signed by
Grantor and Grantee thereby effecting the grant,
lengthy appraisals certified, and resource plans and base data studies
compiled), can be deducted by the land owner from his adjusted gross
income on his annual tax returns. There are limitations on the amount
of deductions that can be taken in each year, and in most circumstances
the deduction must be spread out over at least three years . The deduction,
if not used, can usually be carried forward for later use for up to
six years. However, each individuals’ tax, income, and easement situation
differs, and final details must be carefully scrutinized by an owner’s
legal and tax consultants.
What is the Effect of an Easement? A Conservation Easement
document typically includes two types of uses. Permitted reserved uses, and
non permitted uses. Non permitted uses can involve a variety of quantitative
and qualitative restrictions,
for
instance timbering may be prohibited, or selective timbering may be
permitted in certain areas. All of the future development rights of
a property may be deeded away, or certain rights for a limited number
of homesites in certain areas strictly defined by the Easement may
be retained. Certain resource enhancements and protections may be
mandated, for example, riparian area fences, cross fencing, etc. Each
Conservation Easement deed is unique, and tailored to the specific
piece of property which it will encumber, as negotiated by and between
the owner (or his manager and other consultants), and the recipient
of the easement, which can include such organizations as the Rocky
Mountain Elk Foundation, the Montana Land Reliance, Trout Unlimited,
Ducks
Unlimited, The Nature Conservancy, The Audubon Society, and others.
In the many areas of the Rockies, Local Land Trusts concerned with
very geo-specific resource protections will accept the donation of
an easement.
The End Result. The end result of a conservation
easement whose terms have been carefully thought through and negotiated,
and which is part of a long term capital improvement, agricultural
and resource plan for a working ranch property is that the owner "gets
paid to do the right thing." Wildlife and fisheries habitat is
protected in perpetuity. Development is strictly limited and confined
to non-critical resource areas. View corridors are protected for neighbors
and the public at large, open space preserved, potential greed factors
removed from future generations or owners, agricultural endeavors
continue, an additional land steward in the form of the conservation
agency is added to those watching over the property,
and
the owner is fairly compensated in real live cash based benefits through
tax savings. It is a win, win for all involved.
We are strong believers in Conservation Easements. Our firms have
been instrumental in assisting past clients in negotiation, grant
and/or planning of compensatory and non compensatory Conservation
Easement Deeds on tens of thousands of acres of pristine Rocky
Mountain agricultural and wilderness property in the United States and
Canada, including over sixty stream bank miles of rivers, streams, and
other water bodies.